🔗 Share this article

Champions for a private school system established to teach Native Hawaiians describe a new lawsuit challenging the acceptance policies as a blatant attempt to ignore the intentions of a royal figure who bequeathed her fortune to guarantee a brighter future for her community about 140 years ago.

The Tradition of Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop

These educational institutions were founded in the will of the royal descendant, the great-granddaughter of the founding monarch and the last royal descendant in the royal family. At the time of her death in 1884, the her holdings held about 9% of the Hawaiian islands' total acreage.

Her testament established the learning institutions using those lands and property to finance them. Today, the system encompasses three sites for K-12 education and 30 early learning centers that focus on education rooted in Hawaiian traditions. The schools educate around 5,400 students across all grades and have an financial reserve of roughly $15 billion, a sum exceeding all but about 10 of the United States' top higher education institutions. The schools take no money from the federal government.

Selective Enrollment and Economic Assistance

Entrance is highly competitive at every level, with only about one in five applicants being accepted at the high school. Kamehameha schools furthermore fund approximately 92% of the cost of educating their pupils, with virtually 80% of the learner population also receiving some kind of monetary support depending on financial circumstances.

Past Circumstances and Cultural Significance

Jon Osorio, the head of the Hawaiʻinuiākea School of Hawaiian Knowledge at the the state university, said the educational institutions were created at a era when the Hawaiian people was still on the downward trend. In the 1880s, approximately 50,000 Native Hawaiians were thought to live on the islands, down from a high of from 300,000 to 500,000 individuals at the time of contact with Westerners.

The Hawaiian monarchy was really in a precarious position, especially because the United States was increasingly ever more determined in establishing a permanent base at Pearl Harbor.

The scholar noted during the 1900s, “the majority of indigenous culture was being diminished or even eliminated, or aggressively repressed”.

“During that era, the learning centers was truly the only thing that we had,” Osorio, a former student of the centers, stated. “The institution that we had, that was exclusively for our people, and had the potential at least of keeping us abreast of the general public.”

The Court Case

Now, the vast majority of those admitted at the schools have Hawaiian descent. But the new suit, submitted in district court in the capital, argues that is inequitable.

The legal action was filed by a group called the plaintiff organization, a activist organization located in Virginia that has for years waged a court fight against affirmative action and ancestry-related acceptance. The association challenged the prestigious college in 2014 and ultimately achieved a precedent-setting judicial verdict in 2023 that led to the conservative judges end ethnicity-based enrollment in colleges and universities across the nation.

An online platform launched recently as a forerunner to the legal challenge states that while it is a “excellent educational network”, the institutions' “enrollment criteria expressly prefers students with Native Hawaiian ancestry rather than applicants of other backgrounds”.

“In fact, that preference is so extreme that it is practically unfeasible for a student without Hawaiian ancestry to be accepted to the schools,” the organization claims. “Our position is that focus on ancestry, rather than merit or need, is both unfair and unlawful, and we are dedicated to stopping the schools' improper acceptance criteria via judicial process.”

Political Efforts

The effort is spearheaded by a conservative activist, who has overseen organizations that have submitted over twelve lawsuits challenging the application of ancestry in schooling, commerce and across cultural bodies.

The strategist offered no response to press questions. He informed another outlet that while the association supported the Kamehameha schools’ mission, their services should be open to the entire community, “not exclusively those with a certain heritage”.

Learning Impacts

Eujin Park, an assistant professor at the graduate school of education at the prestigious institution, said the lawsuit aimed at the Kamehameha schools was a notable instance of how the battle to roll back historic equality laws and policies to promote fair access in educational institutions had transitioned from the battleground of higher education to elementary and high schools.

Park noted conservative groups had targeted the Ivy League school “with clear intent” a ten years back.

From my perspective the focus is on the educational institutions because they are a exceptionally positioned establishment… comparable to the approach they selected the college with clear intent.

The scholar explained although race-conscious policies had its opponents as a somewhat restricted tool to increase education opportunity and access, “it was an essential instrument in the repertoire”.

“It served as an element in this broader spectrum of guidelines accessible to learning centers to increase admission and to establish a fairer academic structure,” she commented. “Eliminating that tool, it’s {incredibly harmful